Your search results

My thoughts on the furnished Holiday let market

Posted by Deborah on 05/08/2024
0 Comments

In my blogs and posts, I try to draw attention to anything going on in the local property market. Whether that be lettings, sales or holiday properties.

I haven’t said much about the holiday let market lately, as I know it’s a bit of a hot potato.  There are a couple of recent thoughts, I felt worth sharing though:

Firstly, I want to say that despite all the bad press in recent years, I think its about time we stop demonising holiday let owners in Cornwall. Please hear me out!

Why we need holiday lets

 A lot of small businesses around Hayle, Penzance and St Ives wouldn’t survive through the winter if they didn’t have the influx of holidaymakers’ money through the summer.  In turn, we, as locals would miss out on some of these wonderful businesses and their employment benefits.

Where the real problems lie

 At the risk of sounding like a record with a needle stuck, the only way to truly address the housing crisis in Cornwall is to build more homes.  And I mean truly affordably rental homes and properties locals can afford to buy. 

Pitting locals against holiday let owners is, in my view, not just unfair but also the wrong target.  The press always need headlines and having a bad guy to target, sells copy. Over many years this was residential landlords. But of late, the attention has been focused on holiday let owners. 

I’m still of the mind that there are too many FHL’s (furnished Holiday Lets) in proportion to the amount of affordable homes available for locals to live in. But thats not individual owners fault. Its the local and national governments we should collectively be challenging for their failed housing policies over many decades.

That said, I am pro the double or even triple taxation for second home owners. Empty homes do not serve the local community in any way, so they need to pay their way through taxes.  But holiday let owners are different to second homeowners and the majority do support the community.   They shouldn’t be lumped together, as they often are.

Legislation changes in the FHL industry

However, there are good and bad holiday let owners, as is the case with all business owners. So this is the second point I’d like to highlight today:

A fabulous holiday let owner that I know, has jumped through hoops to comply with the growing levels of legislation FHL owners now have to comply with. As part of this she wrote to the Cornwall fire brigade with a list of questions. These answers jumped out at me:

Q. Since March 2023, how many visits have the fire service made to small guest accommodation in Cornwall and specifically to furnished holiday lets which includes individual properties, groups of converted barns, yurts, treehouses, annexes, caravans etc. in relation to ensuring compliance with this.

A. Since March 2023, Cornwall Fire and Rescue Service have completed 41 Fire Safety Audits at small guest accommodation (furnished holiday lets).

Q. Since March 2023 how many of these properties have been subject to enforcement, improvement or closure notices by Cornwall fire service.

A. Since March 2023, Cornwall Fire and Rescue has issued 3 enforcement notices, 3 prohibitions, 18 notification of deficiencies and 2 referrals for prosecution to small guest accommodation premises.

So whilst this is a tiny overall number, the percentage of these visited properties that were found to be non compliant, is very high. It makes me wonder how many others are also flouting the law, possibly without even realising it.

In summary

I believe we need to dial down the rhetoric when it comes to the holiday let industry in Cornwall. The good ones who support the local communities should be welcome.

But I do wonder whether the recent and new legislation changes coming down the line will weed out the exhausted owners, who’ve done more than their fair share of changeoevers and don’t want the stress of these massive legislation changes and the costs involved. This will hopefully leave us with a smaller number of higher quality, properties. This can only be a good thing for everyone.

If you are a holiday let owner and are not sure if you’re complying with the latest fire safety legislation, this home office /leaflet should help:

A guide to Making your Small paying guest accommodation safe from fire

Please let me know if you agree or disagree with my observations but as always, please keep your comments polite.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Compare Listings